Amy L Witmer, CRNP

University	Degree	Focus	Graduated
Eastern Mennonite University (Professional Education)	Other Degree	Other	2015
Widener University (Graduate School)	Other Degree	Other	2019

Open full review

Review by Anonymous on January 03, 2026 -

WellSpan Family Medicine - Cocalico - 30 West Swartzville Road

Office & Staff Evaluation

Practice Evaluation

Ease of Getting an Appointment Not rated
Courtesy of Practice Staff Not rated
Appearance & Atmosphere of Office Not rated
Handling of Billing & Insurance Not rated
Average Wait Time Not rated

Provider Evaluation

Willingness to Spend Time with You
Listening Skills
Clear explanations Not rated
Trust in Decision Making Not rated
Accuracy of Diagnosis Not rated
Post-Visit Follow-Up Not rated

Comment - “ She was compassionate, caring an... ”

She was compassionate, caring and spent a good amount of time talking and explaining our next plan

Verified Patient

“She was compassionate, caring an...”

She was compassionate, caring and spent a good amount of time talking and explaining our next plan

Anonymous 01/03/2026

Open full review

Review by Anonymous on September 11, 2025 -

WellSpan Family Medicine - Cocalico - 30 West Swartzville Road

Office & Staff Evaluation

Practice Evaluation

Ease of Getting an Appointment Not rated
Courtesy of Practice Staff Not rated
Appearance & Atmosphere of Office Not rated
Handling of Billing & Insurance Not rated
Average Wait Time Not rated

Provider Evaluation

Willingness to Spend Time with You
Listening Skills
Clear explanations Not rated
Trust in Decision Making Not rated
Accuracy of Diagnosis Not rated
Post-Visit Follow-Up Not rated

Comment - “ Amy is always willing to take ex... ”

Amy is always willing to take extra time to listen to any concerns I may have. She is not dismissive when I give a description of what I may be experiencing.

Verified Patient

“Amy is always willing to take ex...”

Amy is always willing to take extra time to listen to any concerns I may have. She is not dismissive when I give a description of what I may be experiencing.

Anonymous 09/11/2025

Open full review

Review by Anonymous on August 20, 2025 -

WellSpan Family Medicine - Cocalico - 30 West Swartzville Road

Office & Staff Evaluation

Practice Evaluation

Ease of Getting an Appointment Not rated
Courtesy of Practice Staff Not rated
Appearance & Atmosphere of Office Not rated
Handling of Billing & Insurance Not rated
Average Wait Time Not rated

Provider Evaluation

Willingness to Spend Time with You
Listening Skills
Clear explanations Not rated
Trust in Decision Making Not rated
Accuracy of Diagnosis Not rated
Post-Visit Follow-Up Not rated

Comment - “ I love Amy... ”

I love Amy

Verified Patient

“I love Amy...”

I love Amy

Anonymous 08/20/2025

Open full review

Review by Anonymous on June 26, 2025 -

WellSpan Family Medicine - Cocalico - 30 West Swartzville Road

Office & Staff Evaluation

Practice Evaluation

Ease of Getting an Appointment Not rated
Courtesy of Practice Staff Not rated
Appearance & Atmosphere of Office Not rated
Handling of Billing & Insurance Not rated
Average Wait Time Not rated

Provider Evaluation

Willingness to Spend Time with You
Listening Skills
Clear explanations Not rated
Trust in Decision Making Not rated
Accuracy of Diagnosis Not rated
Post-Visit Follow-Up Not rated

Comment - “ Amy did a great job about my con... ”

Amy did a great job about my concerns and ordered blood test at my appointment. Definitely had a good experience with her!

Verified Patient

“Amy did a great job about my con...”

Amy did a great job about my concerns and ordered blood test at my appointment. Definitely had a good experience with her!

Anonymous 06/26/2025

Open full review

Review by Anonymous on September 12, 2025 -

WellSpan Family Medicine - Cocalico - 30 West Swartzville Road

Office & Staff Evaluation

Practice Evaluation

Ease of Getting an Appointment Not rated
Courtesy of Practice Staff Not rated
Appearance & Atmosphere of Office Not rated
Handling of Billing & Insurance Not rated
Average Wait Time Not rated

Provider Evaluation

Willingness to Spend Time with You
Listening Skills
Clear explanations Not rated
Trust in Decision Making Not rated
Accuracy of Diagnosis Not rated
Post-Visit Follow-Up Not rated

Comment - “ Excellent experience... ”

Excellent experience

Verified Patient

“Excellent experience...”

Excellent experience

Anonymous 09/12/2025

Open full review

Review by Anonymous on September 06, 2025 -

WellSpan Family Medicine - Cocalico - 30 West Swartzville Road

Office & Staff Evaluation

Practice Evaluation

Ease of Getting an Appointment Not rated
Courtesy of Practice Staff Not rated
Appearance & Atmosphere of Office Not rated
Handling of Billing & Insurance Not rated
Average Wait Time Not rated

Provider Evaluation

Willingness to Spend Time with You
Listening Skills
Clear explanations Not rated
Trust in Decision Making Not rated
Accuracy of Diagnosis Not rated
Post-Visit Follow-Up Not rated

Comment - “ Answered my questions, encourage... ”

Answered my questions, encouraged me in weight loss, took care of my issues.

Verified Patient

“Answered my questions, encourage...”

Answered my questions, encouraged me in weight loss, took care of my issues.

Anonymous 09/06/2025

Open full review

Review by Anonymous on August 14, 2025 -

WellSpan Family Medicine - Cocalico - 30 West Swartzville Road

Office & Staff Evaluation

Practice Evaluation

Ease of Getting an Appointment Not rated
Courtesy of Practice Staff Not rated
Appearance & Atmosphere of Office Not rated
Handling of Billing & Insurance Not rated
Average Wait Time Not rated

Provider Evaluation

Willingness to Spend Time with You
Listening Skills
Clear explanations Not rated
Trust in Decision Making Not rated
Accuracy of Diagnosis Not rated
Post-Visit Follow-Up Not rated

Comment - “ Great doctor.... ”

Great doctor.

Verified Patient

“Great doctor....”

Great doctor.

Anonymous 08/14/2025

Office Hours

Nurse Practitioner - General

Biography

Featured Review See More Reviews

Summary

Provider Training

Photos

Specialties

Languages Spoken

Medical Specialties

Payment Options

Reviews

Office & Staff Evaluation Not rated

Provider Evaluation

Locations

Affiliated Practices

WellSpan Family Medicine - Cocalico

Practice Colleagues

Natalie Hladio, CRNP - Nurse Practitioner, Registered Nurse

Zhanna Demyantsev, CRNP - Nurse Practitioner

Sana Hanafi, MD - Family Medicine Physician

Joanna Brelvi, MD, FAAFP - Family Medicine Physician

Julianne Rees-Swartz, DO - Family Medicine Physician

Dawa Paljor Sherpa, CRNP - Family Medicine Physician

James Fugate, MD - Nurse Practitioner

Rajiv Kalra, DO - Family Medicine Physician

Procedures & Services

Procedures & Treatments Offered

Commonly Prescribed Medications

Accepted Insurance

Accepted Insurance