Jeffrey T Johnston, MD

Open full review

Review by Anonymous on October 23, 2025 -

Mercy Health - St. Elizabeth Boardman Orthopaedics - 8423 Market St. Suite 207

Office & Staff Evaluation

Practice Evaluation

Ease of Getting an Appointment Not rated
Courtesy of Practice Staff Not rated
Appearance & Atmosphere of Office Not rated
Handling of Billing & Insurance Not rated
Average Wait Time Not rated

Provider Evaluation

Willingness to Spend Time with You Not rated
Listening Skills Not rated
Clear explanations Not rated
Trust in Decision Making Not rated
Accuracy of Diagnosis Not rated
Post-Visit Follow-Up Not rated

Comment - “ I had a substantial knee injury ... ”

I had a substantial knee injury that required a fairly big surgery to fix. Dr Johnston took as much time as I needed to explain the details of how they would fix my knee and how they would source the grafts that they would use. The entire medical team was extremely compassionate and proffesional

Verified Patient

“I had a substantial knee injury ...”

Anonymous 10/23/2025

Open full review

Review by Anonymous on October 21, 2025 -

Mercy Health - St. Elizabeth Boardman Orthopaedics - 8423 Market St. Suite 207

Office & Staff Evaluation

Practice Evaluation

Ease of Getting an Appointment Not rated
Courtesy of Practice Staff Not rated
Appearance & Atmosphere of Office Not rated
Handling of Billing & Insurance Not rated
Average Wait Time Not rated

Provider Evaluation

Willingness to Spend Time with You Not rated
Listening Skills Not rated
Clear explanations Not rated
Trust in Decision Making Not rated
Accuracy of Diagnosis Not rated
Post-Visit Follow-Up Not rated

Comment - “ Has been 6 years since first vis... ”

Has been 6 years since first visiting Dr Johnston. Fabulous today as he was back then. Referred another patient to him already

Verified Patient

“Has been 6 years since first vis...”

Has been 6 years since first visiting Dr Johnston. Fabulous today as he was back then. Referred another patient to him already

Anonymous 10/21/2025

Open full review

Review by Anonymous on September 22, 2025 -

Mercy Health - St. Elizabeth Boardman Orthopaedics - 8423 Market St. Suite 207

Office & Staff Evaluation

Practice Evaluation

Ease of Getting an Appointment Not rated
Courtesy of Practice Staff Not rated
Appearance & Atmosphere of Office Not rated
Handling of Billing & Insurance Not rated
Average Wait Time Not rated

Provider Evaluation

Willingness to Spend Time with You Not rated
Listening Skills Not rated
Clear explanations Not rated
Trust in Decision Making Not rated
Accuracy of Diagnosis Not rated
Post-Visit Follow-Up Not rated

Comment - “ Very good... ”

Very good

Verified Patient

“Very good...”

Very good

Anonymous 09/22/2025

Open full review

Review by Anonymous on July 17, 2025 -

Mercy Health - St. Elizabeth Boardman Orthopaedics - 8423 Market St. Suite 207

Office & Staff Evaluation

Practice Evaluation

Ease of Getting an Appointment Not rated
Courtesy of Practice Staff Not rated
Appearance & Atmosphere of Office Not rated
Handling of Billing & Insurance Not rated
Average Wait Time Not rated

Provider Evaluation

Willingness to Spend Time with You Not rated
Listening Skills Not rated
Clear explanations Not rated
Trust in Decision Making Not rated
Accuracy of Diagnosis Not rated
Post-Visit Follow-Up Not rated

Comment - “ Doctor was very professional and... ”

Doctor was very professional and knowledgeable.

Verified Patient

“Doctor was very professional and...”

Doctor was very professional and knowledgeable.

Anonymous 07/17/2025

Open full review

Review by Anonymous on June 19, 2025 -

Mercy Health - St. Elizabeth Boardman Orthopaedics - 8423 Market St. Suite 207

Office & Staff Evaluation

Practice Evaluation

Ease of Getting an Appointment Not rated
Courtesy of Practice Staff Not rated
Appearance & Atmosphere of Office Not rated
Handling of Billing & Insurance Not rated
Average Wait Time Not rated

Provider Evaluation

Willingness to Spend Time with You Not rated
Listening Skills Not rated
Clear explanations Not rated
Trust in Decision Making Not rated
Accuracy of Diagnosis Not rated
Post-Visit Follow-Up Not rated

Comment - “ All of them did a wonderful job... ”

All of them did a wonderful job

Verified Patient

“All of them did a wonderful job...”

All of them did a wonderful job

Anonymous 06/19/2025

Open full review

Review by Anonymous on October 23, 2025 -

Mercy Health - St. Elizabeth Boardman Orthopaedics - 8423 Market St. Suite 207

Office & Staff Evaluation

Practice Evaluation

Ease of Getting an Appointment Not rated
Courtesy of Practice Staff Not rated
Appearance & Atmosphere of Office Not rated
Handling of Billing & Insurance Not rated
Average Wait Time Not rated

Provider Evaluation

Willingness to Spend Time with You Not rated
Listening Skills Not rated
Clear explanations Not rated
Trust in Decision Making Not rated
Accuracy of Diagnosis Not rated
Post-Visit Follow-Up Not rated

Comment - “ Good... ”

Good

Verified Patient

“Good...”

Good

Anonymous 10/23/2025

Open full review

Review by Anonymous on October 16, 2025 -

Mercy Health - St. Elizabeth Boardman Orthopaedics - 8423 Market St. Suite 207

Office & Staff Evaluation

Practice Evaluation

Ease of Getting an Appointment Not rated
Courtesy of Practice Staff Not rated
Appearance & Atmosphere of Office Not rated
Handling of Billing & Insurance Not rated
Average Wait Time Not rated

Provider Evaluation

Willingness to Spend Time with You Not rated
Listening Skills Not rated
Clear explanations Not rated
Trust in Decision Making Not rated
Accuracy of Diagnosis Not rated
Post-Visit Follow-Up Not rated

Comment - “ Everyone was very kind... ”

Everyone was very kind

Verified Patient

“Everyone was very kind...”

Everyone was very kind

Anonymous 10/16/2025

Open full review

Review by Anonymous on August 21, 2025 -

Mercy Health - St. Elizabeth Boardman Orthopaedics - 8423 Market St. Suite 207

Office & Staff Evaluation

Practice Evaluation

Ease of Getting an Appointment Not rated
Courtesy of Practice Staff Not rated
Appearance & Atmosphere of Office Not rated
Handling of Billing & Insurance Not rated
Average Wait Time Not rated

Provider Evaluation

Willingness to Spend Time with You Not rated
Listening Skills Not rated
Clear explanations Not rated
Trust in Decision Making Not rated
Accuracy of Diagnosis Not rated
Post-Visit Follow-Up Not rated

Comment - “ The Youngstown area is very fort... ”

The Youngstown area is very fortunate to have an orthopedic surgeon of Dr. Johnston's skill and demeanor. I've referred by brother to Dr. Johnston's care.

Verified Patient

“The Youngstown area is very fort...”

The Youngstown area is very fortunate to have an orthopedic surgeon of Dr. Johnston's skill and demeanor. I've referred by brother to Dr. Johnston's care.

Anonymous 08/21/2025

Open full review

Review by Anonymous on June 20, 2025 -

Mercy Health - St. Elizabeth Boardman Orthopaedics - 8423 Market St. Suite 207

Office & Staff Evaluation

Practice Evaluation

Ease of Getting an Appointment Not rated
Courtesy of Practice Staff Not rated
Appearance & Atmosphere of Office Not rated
Handling of Billing & Insurance Not rated
Average Wait Time Not rated

Provider Evaluation

Willingness to Spend Time with You Not rated
Listening Skills Not rated
Clear explanations Not rated
Trust in Decision Making Not rated
Accuracy of Diagnosis Not rated
Post-Visit Follow-Up Not rated

Comment - “ Dr took the time to explain X-ra... ”

Dr took the time to explain X-ray and condition of my hips. Discussed all options and was so respectful and mannerly. If I decide to do hip replacements Dr. Johnston will be my go to Dr.

Verified Patient

“Dr took the time to explain X-ra...”

Dr took the time to explain X-ray and condition of my hips. Discussed all options and was so respectful and mannerly. If I decide to do hip replacements Dr. Johnston will be my go to Dr.

Anonymous 06/20/2025

Open full review

Review by Anonymous on June 18, 2025 -

Mercy Health - St. Elizabeth Boardman Orthopaedics - 8423 Market St. Suite 207

Office & Staff Evaluation

Practice Evaluation

Ease of Getting an Appointment Not rated
Courtesy of Practice Staff Not rated
Appearance & Atmosphere of Office Not rated
Handling of Billing & Insurance Not rated
Average Wait Time Not rated

Provider Evaluation

Willingness to Spend Time with You Not rated
Listening Skills Not rated
Clear explanations Not rated
Trust in Decision Making Not rated
Accuracy of Diagnosis Not rated
Post-Visit Follow-Up Not rated

Comment - “ This doctor good...,looking forw... ”

This doctor good...,looking forward in care I get..

Verified Patient

“This doctor good...,looking forw...”

This doctor good...,looking forward in care I get..

Anonymous 06/18/2025

Office Hours

Orthopaedic Surgeon - General, Orthopaedic Surgeon - Orthopaedic Sports Medicine

Biography

Featured Review See More Reviews

Summary

Photos

Specialties

Languages Spoken

Medical Specialties

Payment Options

Reviews

Office & Staff Evaluation Not rated

Locations

Affiliated Practices

Mercy Health - St. Elizabeth Boardman Orthopaedics

Mercy Health - St Elizabeth Boardman Orthopaedics and Sports Medicine

Practice Colleagues

Michael Cratsley, MD - Family Medicine Physician

Mark Colaluca, APRN-CNP - Nurse Practitioner, Orthopaedic Surgeon

Megan Giudici, APRN-CNP - Nurse Practitioner, Orthopaedic Surgeon

Procedures & Services

Procedures & Treatments Offered

Commonly Prescribed Medications

Accepted Insurance

Accepted Insurance